Shindo vs MOTTIV

← All comparisons

The short answer#

Training for one dated race and want a plan written for that distance? MOTTIV. It is a planner, and it is designed for exactly that: pick the event, get the schedule, follow it, with sessions explained on video.

Training year-round, across sports, and want the week to answer to how recovered you actually are? Shindo. It has no library of race plans to hand you — it constructs the coming week from your own load, and reconstructs it when life gets in the way.

Neither is a better version of the other. One sells structure decided in advance, the other sells structure decided each week.

What each one is#

MOTTIV builds training plans for distances from couch-to-5K up through the marathon and ultra distances, and across the triathlon range from sprint to full-distance, plus duathlon, gran fondo and swimrun. It layers in strength sessions and yoga for endurance athletes, explains sessions with video, syncs to Strava with custom workout names, and has a community and a free Basic tier. It runs on iPhone, Android and the web, and the web side is the centre of the product. US pricing was $19.99 a month, $179.99 a year, or $199.99 for lifetime access, and the app held 71 ratings at 4.80 — all checked 30 August 2026. One fact belongs on the table with the rest: as of that same check, the iPhone app had not been updated since 24 July 2024. The company is clearly still active — it cut prices and launched the free tier well after that date — but the mobile app has not moved.

Shindo is an iPhone app for running, cycling, swimming and triathlon, requiring an iPhone 11 or newer. It reads recovery and training data from Apple Health and computes readiness on the phone from sleep, HRV, resting heart rate and current form, together with training stress per session and the fitness, fatigue and form curves. It then generates the training week — phases, an easy/hard balance, a cap on how fast load may grow — matches what you actually did against what was planned, and sets nutrition targets from the load you did. Thresholds and zones come from your accumulated history.

Where they differ#

MOTTIV figures checked 30 August 2026 on the US storefront. Shindo’s price is in its App Store listing and varies by region, so it is not reproduced here.

The thing Shindo genuinely does not have#

A plan library. If you want to type in a race distance and a date and receive sixteen weeks laid out in advance, MOTTIV does that and Shindo does not. Shindo builds the week ahead, informed by the weeks behind, and it will not hand you the whole block up front — that is a deliberate design, but if your question is “show me the schedule to the start line”, it is a real answer of “no”.

It is worth being blunt about a second gap: MOTTIV’s strength and yoga layer is one of the most praised parts of its reviews, and Shindo’s disciplines are running, cycling, swimming and triathlon. If strength work is a scheduled part of your training rather than something you do on your own, MOTTIV covers it and Shindo does not.

Decided in advance, or decided each week#

A distance plan is a hypothesis written before the block starts: this is what a person like you should be able to absorb over the next four months. It is a good hypothesis, especially for a first race at a distance, and following one is far better than improvising.

Shindo starts from the other end. It has no opinion about what a person like you can absorb; it has an opinion about what you have absorbed, measured as fitness, fatigue and the balance between them, and it constructs the next week inside limits computed from your own history. When a week is missed, swapped or shortened, the sessions you actually did are counted honestly — a ride instead of a run is not a zero — and the remainder re-flows rather than being marked failed.

The trade-off is visibility. A library plan lets you see week 12 today. An engine-built week does not, because week 12 depends on weeks 1 through 11.

Which one to pick#

Pick MOTTIV if you have a race on the calendar and want a plan built for it, if you want strength and yoga inside that plan, if you want sessions explained on video, if you want your workouts to land in Strava automatically, if you are on Android or prefer working on the web, or if you would rather buy access once than subscribe. Its free Basic tier makes trying it inexpensive, and its reviews are unusually positive.

Pick Shindo if the plan is not the hard part — staying honest about your load is. It fits if you train year-round rather than race-to-race, if you cross-train enough that a single-sport plan would miss most of your fatigue, if you want thresholds and zones from your own history rather than from a template, and if you want the week to change when your recovery does. The methodology sets out how the plan is bounded, and the guide on reading fitness, fatigue and form covers the curves it is built on.

Can you run both? Partly. MOTTIV can own the schedule while Shindo watches the load, provided the workouts you complete reach Apple Health — Shindo reads nothing from Strava and nothing from MOTTIV directly. What does not work is letting both author the same week.

Claims about MOTTIV were checked against its public pages on the date shown above and are not warranted to stay current — pricing and features change without notice, and the vendor's own site is authoritative. Shindo is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by MOTTIV. Product names are used only to identify the products discussed. Found something out of date? Tell us and it gets corrected.

Read next

Shindo is free on the App Store — readiness, the weekly plan and the load charts need no subscription.